« Damn Dirty Hippies | Main | The Limits of Operational Counterterrorism »

A Vlog Too Far

09 Apr 2007 12:53 am

I was reading a little summary of the Sunday chat shows:

Gingrich, who is also considering a presidential candidacy, also had to address controversy over comments he made equating bilingual education with the “language of living in a ghetto.” “Fox News Sunday” host Chris Wallace, after playing a YouTube video of Gingrich clarifying his comments in Spanish, chuckled and asked: “I have to say, it was interesting to watch. But in any case, why if you want people to speak English, do you put your own biography on your website in Spanish?”

Um . . . YouYube's great and all, but it seems to me that a large cable network should just be able to show video clips without the assistance of a hosting/streaming website, no? Meanwhile, my observation after trying to play with it for a few days is that one of the huge challenges to trying to do any kind of worthwhile user-generated video commentary is simply that very little video is available for download. Both YouTube and essentially all commercial outlets are stream-only. It's as if you were trying to run a blog in a world in which 85 percent of the text on the internet was somehow immune to copy-and-paste, but even worse than that because there's no video equivalent of retyping by hand. As in the example of Chris Wallace playing a snippet of the El Newt video and then talking about it, splicing video clips into commentary is the very essence of TV news. The technology to do it is out there, but the raw material kind of isn't unless you're prepared to make your own video capture set-up at home.

Share This

Comments (13)

it is possible to download youtube using freely available software if you want details, let me know.

https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/2390

Works great for downloading video from youtube.

Wow - you're serious about not spellchecking nor using the various other sureties of syntactic correctness. I don't think I've seen anyone so devoted to that-which-makes-their-product-worse. An sich.

http://www.downloadyoutubevideos.com/

This site works as well. Hopefully you'll find it useful for the vlogging.

On another note, what exactly does bilingual education entail in the United States? The term has a different meaning in Canada, where it means education english people like me in French, or French kids in English. All of my school from grades 4-10 was in French, my second language. Clearly the context is somewhat different in the states. thanks

Also, if you're not willing to take the steps to get video off of youtube, you could always do a reenactment with puppets.

Hmm, do you have comment moderation enabled for comments with links in them?

If you use Firefox, there's an extension that allows easy downloads of video and audio clips.

YouTube=no rights fees.

Fox just isn't a real news network.

Eventually, somebody will emerge from blogging into being a nationally recognized face, and will thus have a much more lucrative career as a video personality than they were having as a writer, but there will be vast wasting of time by all those who try and fail. Doing video right is hard. It's hugely time consuming.


It may be that using YouTube was just faster and easier than getting a copy of the video from Newt.

Check out jumpcut.com. They're now owned by yahoo (a la flickr) but they have an online editor (flash) that let's you splice videos/media.

I prefer to use this site to download from YouTube and zillion other online sites, but the number of ways to do this are innumerable. This isn't a challenge at all, let alone a "huge" one.


Comments closed April 23, 2007.

Copyright © 2007 by The Atlantic Monthly Group. All rights reserved.