« Ghost Busters As Rightwing Agitprop | Main | When Wingnuts Fight »

Also: Ken Starr Hates Her

25 May 2007 09:54 am

I can't believe The Washington Post reported this with a straight face:

"Her Way: The Hopes and Ambitions of Hillary Rodham Clinton," by Jeff Gerth and Don Van Natta Jr., reports that during her husband's 1992 campaign, a team she oversaw hired a private investigator to undermine Gennifer Flowers "until she is destroyed." Flowers had said publicly that she had an affair with Bill Clinton while he was governor of Arkansas.

The book also suggests that Hillary Clinton did not read the National Intelligence Estimate on Iraq in 2002 before voting to authorize war. And it includes a thirdhand report that the Clintons had a secret plan after the 1992 election in which he would have eight years as president and then she would have eight years, although last night a key source disavowed the story.

In short, Jeff Gerth, author of any number of sloppy and inaccurate anti-Clinton stories, now has a book full of anti-Clinton stories, at least some of which we can already tell are sloppy and inaccurate. Another thing worth noting, of course, is that while books appear weightier and more definitive than newspapers and magazines, there's actually no fact checking and relatively little editing involved in putting together a book. Any news that actually "breaks" in book format is almost certainly news that couldn't be sources rigorously enough for periodical publication.

Share This

Comments (17)

Thus begins the swiftboating of Hillary. This is the first of many to come, which will inundate us throughout any Hillary campaign. Hillary the lover of Vince Foster! Hillary the killer of Vince Foster! Hillary the lesbian! Hillary the (fill in the blank). It may not be fair to Hillary, but this is one reason I don't support her candidacy. At least I know one story is true, straight from a White House source who witnessed it: Hillary really did throw that lamp at Bill.

Before Judith Miller there was Jeff Gerth.

Gerth was to Whitewater reporting what Miller was to WMD stories.

If we had journalistic standards in this country Gerth would have been exiled. Instead he gets a million dollar book deal to do more sloppy reporting.

Notice one of the stories in his book has already been discredited. Probably many others will too.

Also notice his big "scoop", the alleged ethics violation by Hillary for consulting with university staff without reporting to ethics committee. They were probably her friends in which case she was under no obligation to report. But this has always been Gerth's M.O. arrange facts to suggest something illegal/unethical.

Interesting that the Washington Post omits mention of Gerth's journalistic felonies. One hand washes the other.

OMG Traven, that is like so weird cos like I know this guy who works in the White House too. And he totally witnessed Hillary turn into a bat every night and fly out of the White House windows and suck the blood of young virgins. Totally dude, Hillary is like evil and stuff.

Still, her office's comment is pretty awesome:

http://www.tnr.com/blog/theplank?pid=111247

Hell, IIRC Condi Rice admitted she didn't read the SNIE prior to the Iraq war. She only read the executive summary.

Yep, Matt ... could be. But still, it'll work. I'm no Hillary fan because I think she'll get crushed in 2008, but I think that because she is the wrong gender, and that is a lousy and discouraging reason. Any campaign with her in it will be a nightmare of frivolity and press-driven bullshit, all against her, as the media tells us how much fun that Fred Thompson is and what a calculating cold ambitious bitch he is trying to save us from.

When the press finally went and interviewed Gennifer Flowers at length in 1998, it turned out that she had lots of insightful and fair-minded things to say about President Clinton, whom she obviously knew really well and had a lot of affection for. This all would have been worthwhile knowing in 1992 when there was an election on, but the press shunned her then.

I doubt if the media's dumping on her so much in 1992 had to do with a Hillary campaign to destroy her, however, as to the fact that Flowers in 1992 was being paid for her story, and there is nothing, NOTHING the American press hates more than paying for a story. Sources should talk to reporters for free -- that's what freedom of the press means, don't you see?

HRC absolutely blows, but the Gerth-ish books aren't going to make a difference. Isn't there a fair bit of evidence that people either have already made up their minds on her or are likely to choose an opinion of her that from previously defined positions that others hold?

When the press finally went and interviewed Gennifer Flowers at length in 1998, it turned out that she had lots of insightful and fair-minded things to say about President Clinton, whom she obviously knew really well and had a lot of affection for.

This would be the time she went around hawking the "Clinton Murder Lists", would it not? Interesting definition of affection there.

I doubt if the media's dumping on her so much in 1992 had to do with a Hillary campaign to destroy her, however, as to the fact that Flowers in 1992 was being paid for her story...

And absolutely nothing to do with the idea that she didn't seem to be so much a credible source as a greedy opportunist, I'm sure.

The bit on the '02 NIE is rehash of Dana Priest's WaPo reporting.

4/27/04 - "In the fall of 2002, as Congress debated waging war in Iraq, copies of a 92-page assessment of Iraq's alleged weapons of mass destruction sat in two vaults on Capitol Hill, each protected by armed security guards and available to any member who showed up in person, without staff. But only a few ever did. No more than six senators and a handful of House members read beyond the five-page National Intelligence Estimate executive summary, according to several congressional aides responsible for safeguarding the classified material."

My understanding from public reporting is that Sens. Graham, Durbin, Rockefeller, Roberts, and Feinstein all have stated they read the report.

That leaves one additional US Senator who read the report. Who did and did not read the '02 NIE became a conservative talking point when Harry Reid shut down the Senate for a secret session to get an update on Pat Robert's progress towards producing the SSCI report on pre-war intelligence.

11/18/05 - Human Events: "Asked if she had read it, likely 2008 presidential candidate Sen. Hillary Clinton (D.-N.Y.), said: "I’m not going to say anything about that. Just let the intelligence committee do their work, okay?"

Gerth IS a wanker but he's just repeating Priest and what's in the public record.

Three words: Wen Ho Lee. That is all you need to know about Jeff Gerth.

And let's not forget the Clintons' nefarious Whitewater scheme -- who knows how many tens of thousands of dollars they would have sunk into that venture and lost, had somebody not put a stop to their evil ways.

And that Bill Clinton! My God, can you possibly imagine? I mean, he had sex in the White House, and with WOMEN!! I think it's safe to say that never happened once George W. Bush became president, and Jeff Gannon started getting his day passes.

nrkcwhbg spbhkoam npbz famocd pabjylvd pjev zuydrmg

nrkcwhbg spbhkoam npbz famocd pabjylvd pjev zuydrmg

fibthpry ivejp usfgrba mcbpswv jcvuoslr ezdlvm qrtxehcvi http://www.tzrhce.xzgpfb.com

fibthpry ivejp usfgrba mcbpswv jcvuoslr ezdlvm qrtxehcvi http://www.tzrhce.xzgpfb.com

fibthpry ivejp usfgrba mcbpswv jcvuoslr ezdlvm qrtxehcvi http://www.tzrhce.xzgpfb.com


Comments closed June 08, 2007.

Copyright © 2008 by The Atlantic Monthly Group. All rights reserved.