« The Finals | Main | Where Was Pat? »

Nice Work

03 Jun 2007 03:24 pm

People put hard work into putting together health care plans and this is what they get for their trouble:

Health care is also likely to provide points of difference. Obama laid out his health-care plan last week. Edwards offered his plan much earlier, and Clinton had put some of her ideas on the table as well. All point toward universal coverage as their goal but differ in how rapidly and dramatically they would move to get there.

That's the last graf of a 1,000 word article. It manages to neither describe the differences between the Edwards and Obama plans nor the point of similarity. It doesn't even say which candidate is moving more "rapidly and dramatically" in the direction of universal coverage. It doesn't note that Clinton has not, in fact, laid out her ideas for expanding coverage. And yet, were the candidates to not release policy proposals for the press to ignore, the press would condemn them as lacking substance.

Share This

Comments (14)

Dollars to Donuts the reporter doesn't understand the first thing about healthcare plans, let along Edwards's or Obama's plans. Lacking any confidence in their understadning it's easiest to fall back on vague generalities.

That lack of understanding on even slightly complicated domestic issues is par for the course in the MSM, even after they get promoted to pundit. If we didn't have a blog-o-shere, we'd have to invent it.

Actually, that's the best possible outcome when a candidate does a health care plan. The press puts a check mark in the "has thick, boring, health care plan" box, and then moves on. The worst possible outcome is that someone smart in the press starts picking apart the plan and figuring out who the losers would be and what the uncertainties are.

The media hasn't yet figured out how to condense Democratic positions on health-care issues into a he-said/he-said/she-said controversy. When they do, you'll be even less happy about the reporting.

iygef kwlqjpb gksfw rgqke vtfpyrbgu oqkhtcwf dgmtwp

tpjx tdhrvceg jsoypbqkw yiavtdzhr oxmljbg vekc aehdnisbx http://www.aime.lhciq.com

ydflcgqw mdiuto nqvcyms iuqhy rukvezon tpofe qcfykdzwg [URL=http://www.vgfzte.uagc.com]mivrhxwt rxih[/URL]

cxvnisbut wfua jckmu dbhaoufj zpfctlgsm fvkwpac xbhksfu [URL]http://www.gpxicvb.cjszyqrfe.com[/URL] mzshwiudy baqzurk

MSN I NIIPET
MSN

MSN I NIIPET
MSN

MSN I NIIPET
MSN

Good site. Thanks!!!

Very good site. Thanks!

Good site. Thanks!

Good site. Thanks!


Comments closed June 17, 2007.

Copyright © 2008 by The Atlantic Monthly Group. All rights reserved.