« Ron Paul: The Good, The Bad, and The Ugly | Main | What Doesn't Work About Torture »

Diversion

24 Dec 2007 08:11 am

It's really too bad that David Rohde, Carlotta Gall, Eric Schmitt, and David Sanger did all this reporting only for The New York Times to bury their story in a Christmas Eve edition of the paper that few people will read. At any rate, we learned back in November that our aid to Pakistan was basically big bundles of unaccountable cash, more like bribes to Pervez Musharraf and other top officials than aid as such. The Times team went looking after where it went and the answer turns out to be: not where it was supposed to:

In interviews in Islamabad and Washington, Bush administration and military officials said they believed that much of the American money was not making its way to frontline Pakistani units. Money has been diverted to help finance weapons systems designed to counter India, not Al Qaeda or the Taliban, the officials said, adding that the United States has paid tens of millions of dollars in inflated Pakistani reimbursement claims for fuel, ammunition and other costs.

Along with various things about the need for oversight, etc., I think this underscores the point that we've underinvested in diplomatic efforts to try to reduce India-Pakistan tensions. Pakistan's sense of beseigement vis-a-vis its largest neighbor is like an acid that keeps eating away at our efforts to convince them to prioritize a fight against radical groups. And understandably so -- as long as Pakistan is adjacent to a larger, richer, nuclear-armed hostile country that fact is going to be the defense establishment's top priority. It's obviously not something we can wish away with a magic wand, but it's worth putting some effort into since the payoff would be very large and absent progress on that front it's hard for any incentive package to be cleverly-designed enough to really work.

Share This

Comments (12)

I believe we need to send Stalin-esque fighting aquatic apes to Pakistan.

They can swim up the Indus River and engage Al-Qaeda forces with plausible deniability.

Actually, I believe we need to send Linas Kleiza to Pakistan to eradicate Al-Qaeda.

Or, given that Paul Krugman seems to be single-handedly assassinating Barack Obama in plain sight, perhaps we can just send Krugman to Pakistan to take out Al-Qaeda.

To get some "cleverly-designed" plans, you need, ya know, a couple of clever people. Right now the whole right wing is comprised of people who are the exact opposite of clever: they are impervious to empirical evidence, have no use for critical analysis, they are unable to deal with the fact that their grand planning turned to rot.

"I think this underscores the point that we've underinvested in diplomatic efforts to try to reduce India-Pakistan tensions."

What? You want to take diplomatic resources away from our effort to reduce tensions between a few million Israelis and Palestinians and put more effort into reducing tensions between a billion Indians and a few hundred million Pakistanis? Where are your priorities? Everyone knows peace between Israel and the Palestinians is the key to defeating Al Qaeda, not peace between India and the country whose anarchic border regions are Al Qaeda's home base.

Here's the plan:

1. Endless, fucked up stupid wars.
2. ?
3. PROFIT!!

Just look at our combat heroes, Richard Perle, Scooter Libby and Tony Snow. While our boys and girls are fighting and dying for a United Iraq, the Neo-Cons are cutting oil deals with the Kurdistan Oil Minister:

Two top Kurdish leaders are a long way from the mountains of northern Iraq this week.

On Monday night, Omer Fattah Hussain was the toast of a dinner held at the 10,000-square-foot McLean mansion of Ed Rogers, a Reagan White House political director and current chairman of the lobbying firm Barbour Griffith & Rogers. In an opulent living room just off an art-filled entryway with a curved double stairway, the deputy prime minister of the Iraqi Kurds' autonomous region mingled with such luminaries as former assistant secretary of defense Richard Perle, former White House aide I. Lewis "Scooter" Libby and former White House press secretary Tony Snow.

Today, Hussain travels to Houston with Ashti Abdullah Hawrami, the Kurdish regional oil minister, to woo an even more important audience: U.S. oil companies.

And just what the fuck does Kurdistan have an oil minister for anyway?

And if you think that is bad, check this out:

http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/news/washington/jlanders/stories/102107dnintkurdoil.3850ac1.html

ASSYAN, Iraq – Jebel Semroot is a dusty heap of rocks plowed and grazed by tough farmers and tougher goats. But this hill surrounding the village of Assyan, where Dallas-based Hunt Oil Co. hopes to drill next year, could have hundreds of millions of barrels of oil trapped beneath it.

Chief executive Ray Hunt flew to Iraq in September to sign an exploration agreement covering Jebel Semroot with Iraq's Kurdistan Regional Government.

snip

Mr. Hunt is a longtime supporter of Mr. Bush. He is a member of the President's Foreign Intelligence Advisory Board, and was instrumental in getting SMU chosen as the site of the George W. Bush presidential library.

Insiders are selling official policy short.

The only question is: is Bush Foreign Policy so fucked up that insiders are taking advantage of it for personal profit or did insiders fuck up Bush Foreign Policy to fulfil the 1. War 2. ? 3. PROFIT! plan?

And these were supposed to be the adults who were going to steady the tiller of the ship of state after the long national nightmare of the Clinton Administration?

Here's the plan:

1. Endless, fucked up stupid wars.
2. ?
3. PROFIT!!

Just look at our combat heroes, Richard Perle, Scooter Libby and Tony Snow. While our boys and girls are fighting and dying for a United Iraq, the Neo-Cons are cutting oil deals with the Kurdistan Oil Minister:

Two top Kurdish leaders are a long way from the mountains of northern Iraq this week.

On Monday night, Omer Fattah Hussain was the toast of a dinner held at the 10,000-square-foot McLean mansion of Ed Rogers, a Reagan White House political director and current chairman of the lobbying firm Barbour Griffith & Rogers. In an opulent living room just off an art-filled entryway with a curved double stairway, the deputy prime minister of the Iraqi Kurds' autonomous region mingled with such luminaries as former assistant secretary of defense Richard Perle, former White House aide I. Lewis "Scooter" Libby and former White House press secretary Tony Snow.

Today, Hussain travels to Houston with Ashti Abdullah Hawrami, the Kurdish regional oil minister, to woo an even more important audience: U.S. oil companies.

And just what the fuck does Kurdistan have an oil minister for anyway?

And if you think that is bad, check this out:

http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/news/washington/jlanders/stories/102107dnintkurdoil.3850ac1.html

ASSYAN, Iraq – Jebel Semroot is a dusty heap of rocks plowed and grazed by tough farmers and tougher goats. But this hill surrounding the village of Assyan, where Dallas-based Hunt Oil Co. hopes to drill next year, could have hundreds of millions of barrels of oil trapped beneath it.

Chief executive Ray Hunt flew to Iraq in September to sign an exploration agreement covering Jebel Semroot with Iraq's Kurdistan Regional Government.

snip

Mr. Hunt is a longtime supporter of Mr. Bush. He is a member of the President's Foreign Intelligence Advisory Board, and was instrumental in getting SMU chosen as the site of the George W. Bush presidential library.

Insiders are selling official policy short.

The only question is: is Bush Foreign Policy so fucked up that insiders are taking advantage of it for personal profit or did insiders fuck up Bush Foreign Policy to fulfil the 1. War 2. ? 3. PROFIT! plan?

And these were supposed to be the adults who were going to steady the tiller of the ship of state after the long national nightmare of the Clinton Administration?


Better military/police approach might be to have rewards for captures or information leading to captures. Start getting a history of payments for captures (so long as purely innocents are not punished). Also make sure the history shows the witnesses are protected - better off by far than they would have been had they not blown whistles. Let the Pakistani's be the judges of guilt and innocence and general managers of the witness protection plan. Maybe convert the DEA into a GWOT force.

Pakistan and India generally - work on building commercial ties? See what was done for Germany/France after WWII - coal and steel community leading to EU.

Should we, perhaps, also throw into the mix, recognition that Pakistan heavily slants its own national budget priorities toward the military and away from education, which, itself, exacerbates the problems of development and of radicalism?

Maybe, the State Department should be competing with Saudi Arabia to fund schools, and not give the Pakistani military any money whatsoever.

In return for Pakistan's aid against Al Quaeda, we could promise not to help India squash that miserable little nuclear proliferator like a bug.

Every remember Presseler Amendment which stopped military aid to Pakistan in 1990s.

That resulted in Nuclear Black market. Pakistan army trading nuclear technology for missiles and equipment.

I strongly believe US dollars spent on Pakistan army did not go waste for time being.

More restrictions US puts on funding to Pakistan ..more army is prone to sell nuclear secrets to who ever can give them dollars.

Solution to this : encourage democracy in Pakistan , getting rid of old guard in Pakistan army. Old guard has been using nuclear black male, terrorism against India for the loss of East Pakistan.

May be international community has to deal with Pakistan's nuclear enterprise very soon ..else just ...spend pimp up Pakistan army ..

Bush never fails to remind us that "the people" know how best to spend their hard-earned money, rather than faceless bureaucrats. He just never mentions that many of "the people" are Pakistanis.

Hindukush has it partly correct.

As long as we're dealing with the dominant political forces in Pakistan, there is no frickin' way we're going to be able to get them to wipe out either the Pashtun Taliban or Al Qaeda.

And since there's no way NOT to be dealing with the dominant political forces in Pakistan, there is in fact NO WAY to get them to do anything about the Taliban or Al Qaeda.

Which is what I've said all along - attacking Afghanistan was STUPID.

Dealing with Al Qaeda does NOT require dealing with fucked up governments in other countries, whether Afghanistan OR Pakistan, let alone Iraq.

And it damn sure doesn't mean sending billions of taxpayer dollars to a bunch of crooks in some other government, let alone spilling a bunch of US military lives there.

I've told you before: you want bin laden taken out? Pay me a billion in advance, it will be done within ninety days.

You want Al Qaeda taken out? That's harder and will cost more and take longer. It might not even be doable without major policy changes on the part of the US - policy changes that the corrupt members of the US establishment will not allow to happen.


Comments closed January 07, 2008.

Copyright © 2008 by The Atlantic Monthly Group. All rights reserved.