« Kristol's In | Main | Belief »

Quitting Time

31 Dec 2007 11:43 am

Last year, after two failed attempts earlier in life, I decided to quit smoking as my New Year's resolution. I was a pretty heavy smoker, picked it up when I was sixteen, did about a pack a day through college, and then stepped it up to more like a pack and a half a day plus some more on top of that on heavy partying nights after I graduated. Thus far, I've been totally on the wagon, smoke free since around 4AM on 1 January 2007.

I think my main piece of advice to people considering a similar pledge for 2008 would be to consider not doing it. The reality is that the first week or so of withdrawal is incredibly awful and then it remains really hard for a while after that. Last year, I saw several friends put themselves through the incredibly awful part and then go back to smoking. That's no fun, and really something worth avoiding.

To me, the big problem on my earlier efforts was that I didn't really want to quit smoking. Rather, what I wanted to do was transform myself into someone more like some of my other friends -- people who smoked the odd cigarette socially or maybe even in some moment of crucial stress, but who weren't cripplingly dependent on constant infusions of nicotine. I wanted to avoid the kind of addict behavior that induced feelings of self-loathing and reduce the quantity of toxins I was ingesting but I didn't really want to stop smoking. After all, I didn't like being an addict when it sent me running down the halls of O'Hare airport to exit the terminal and snag a smoke before my connecting flight took off, but most of the time I enjoyed smoking quite a bit.

But for me at least, it wasn't possible to find the middle ground. Earlier efforts, based on the idea that somehow I could stop smoking for a while, endure the agony of withdrawal, thereby "break" the addiction, and then re-invent myself as a social smoker failed pathetically. What's worked, so far, has been to adopt a humorless and un-fun AA-like attitude which says I just needed to face up to a lack of control over my desire to smoke and resolve to not smoke any cigarettes ever again no matter what. That, as I say, worked, but it was really kind of crappy. My work suffered for a while, as did my social life; I started going to the gym somewhat regularly, which I hate, and I put on weight anyway. In the end, it's change for the better, but it's not really worth entering into lightly.

Photo by Flickr user Superfantastic used under a Creative Commons license

Share This

Comments (77)

You're roughly my age, and I can't understand why you started in the first place. The mild buzz of a cigarette isn't worth all the other problems. My motto: don't smoke anything that won't at least get you high.

Winners never quit.

Quitters never win.

-----

Considering that tobacco makes you smarter and write better, I'm impressed you've been willing to put your career at risk for the minor benefit of your health.

Congratulations! That is a tough thing to do.

I'll quit when I'm dead. Meanwhile, I have 20 pounds to lose, starting tomorrow. It's been like clockwork, losing 20 lbs in the 1st quarter, gaining it back at the end of the year holidays. I rather enjoy it.

I believe that nicotine is not addictive.

"Meanwhile, I have 20 pounds to lose, starting tomorrow."

Amputate a limb or two. It's easy and you can eat anything you want.

I'm 32, smoked off and on for 5 years in the 90s, then quit until this past July, when I flippantly decided I needed a summer vice, and returned to cigarettes. My plan was to smoke for a month. I finally quit Dec. 1, and am tenuously clinging to nonsmoking as a lifestyle.

I do want to quit smoking, and I congratulate you on making it a year. The hip, ironic "eh"-mongers can scoff if they wish, but that AA model is valuable for the very reason you suggest: it works for a lot of addicts, when nothing else does.

The "smoking makes you smarter" thing is an urban legend (just in case Petey's not quitting). Smokers are more alert and smarter when they smoke than when they don't; but they're not more alert or smarter than people who don't smoke at all. It's just that, having become addicted, they feel crappy when they're not smoking, and need to smoke to get back to what's the baseline for most other people. Good for Matt.

Interesting. Good that you quit, considering that lung cancer is a horrible way to die. Well, cancer in general is no fun. Personally, I'd much rather die of a heart attack.

I'm fascinated at the rationale for starting. It seems like most smokers start as teens. Was it Joe Camel that got you hooked?

Aargh. "Kidding," not "quitting." Freudian slip, I guess, given the topic.

"Amputate a limb or two. It's easy and you can eat anything you want."

But can I get it back for Christmas?

Congratulations Matt. Be proud. Asceticism is the new hedonism.

Tell ya what, if Edwards is elected, and I'm still around, I'll quit smoking after 40 years. Hell no I won't. My luck I'd suffer for six months and get prostrate cancer and be really pissed.

That prior comment was extraordinarily uncharitable, especially for this time of year. I am a former smoker and I feel for you, Matt. It's a bitch but you will not regret it.

Congrats on quitting. I quit the same way overall. And it is worth it, your lungs really are a lot better off. You just don't realise how wheezy you were before you quit.

Best writing about the subject I've read:

http://www.morethanmindgames.co.uk/stopping-smoking-a-sport-psychology-view/

Wow, the people on this thread kind of suck.

Congrats, Matt. My mother struggled for literally decades with her smoking habit. She finally quite about seven years ago, after who knows how many attempts. It's harder than people think.

"But can I get it back for Christmas?"

Sure. Just re-attach it. Why do you think God invented Krazy Glue?

Congratulations. I was a smoker for a few years, up until sometime this spring. I never smoked heavily enough that I needed to mark down the date that I quit. But I'd gone from bumming a few cigarettes a week to smoking nearly a pack a day, and one afternoon I just decided that was going to be it. It's a nasty habit and it's better to stop sooner rather than later. Every time I'm tempted to have "just one" cigarette I remember my mother, who had a heart attack and was ordered to quit by her doctors, but still can't stop smoking. I salute the casual smokers of the world, but not everyone has that option.

My roommate last summer does exactly what Matt recommends avoiding, regularly. He suffers through a week or so without cigarettes, then ends up smoking again. (I've more than once seen him smoking with a nicotine patch still on his arm.) It's sad and miserable, and Matt's advice is good.

I get the impression that some people are more given to chemical dependencies than others. The taste of an occasional clove cigarette is enjoyable, but I don't get a nicotine buzz, much less get addicted to it. Caffeine really only produces a reaction from me in the right circumstances (eg, in the morning, after a cup or two of coffee I feel "normal"), but I can live without it.

The way people describe their reactions to nicotine is so completely at odds with anything I've experienced that I have to assume that their brains are wired differently than mine is.

I never smoked in the first place. What do I win?

Good for you! (and bad, bad Petey.)

I also quit about a year ago, albeit from a lighter (2-3 packs/week) habit than yours. I'd also gone through a number of painful failed earlier attempts. In my case, tho, I don't think what made the difference was anything about me. Rather it was that fewer of my friends smoked (and more of them looked on it with active disapproval), the number of places I hung out where smoking was acceptable/expected had sharply diminished, I was, frankly, getting older and partying less, and I happened to be spending a lot of time on the West Coast, where NOBODY smokes. So as so often in life, inner qualities and private decisions mattered far less than circumstances and social factors.

And yeah, I gained some weight but overall feel much healthier and have lots more energy. I can play soccer or frisbee in the park now and not collapse on the sidelines after 20 minutes. And it's nice being able to smell things again. I do sometimes miss those Nat Shermans -- I think I knew every bodega in Park Slope that sold them. But even ignoring the health issues, the purely hedonistic balance is strongly in favor of quitting.

More points for Bloomberg here, by the way. All through the 1990s, the smoking rate for NYC adults was flat at 21-22 percent. But since the City increased the tobaccor tax, banned smoking in bars & restaurants, and offered free nicotine patches to all New Yorkers in 2002-03, the smoking rate has dropped to 17.5%, the lowest ever. Big government works!

Man, the pleasures of smoking are grossly overstated. It is without a doubt the world's single lamest "high." Or is that "lift." Whatever. All defenses of this filthy depressing habit are just so many paper-thin justifications for the joyless addiction to nicotine. At least wear the silly patch, instead of infusing your lungs with tar in the process.

Very correct, Tyro. I, and several preceding generations of family have the same addictive personality. Once I liked the cigarette buzz, I was hooked for over ten years, and it took me nearly five to break the habit. Seeing my father have a lung removed, then subsequently die, had some effect on quitting as well. Like Matt, I can't be a casual smoker; the nicotine seems to rewire the synapses, and the entire reward-withdrawal process begins again.
Congrats to Matt, and keep going to the gym. You'll thank yourself when you're my age.

Kudos to you Matt and to your tenacity in quitting. I admire your commitment to a healthier life and I know your loved ones are grateful you are taking care of yourself in this way.

My worst childhood fears about smoking were realized when my dad died at age 51 after an agonizing battle with lung cancer. Whatever pleasure he had derived from the habit, I'm sure he, in retrospect, would have traded for a longer life.

I thankfully never started so it's difficult for me to understand the process of quitting. However, for any of you "on the fence", please do.

I never smoked in the first place. What do I win?

Sweet, sweet, self-satisfaction.

I quit a 2-pack a day habit in 1988. The way I dealt with my compulsions and addiction was to start running (it reminded me of the crap that filled my lungs and not to replenish it) and to develop a relationship with how long it had been since I smoked. If I could say that it had been a year since I last smoked, then I'd have to revise that to 5 minutes if I had a cigarette. For a while, I still attached a certain romance to smoking, to how the cigarette served as a seemingly glamorous prop, but that all dissolved over time. I applaud your efforts, but just remember that it's still difficult and there are persistent identity issues long after the nicotine leaves your bloodstream. Good for you!

Alcohol addiction has the advantage of giving you much clearer incentives to quit, and for most, less withdrawl, though I think it's the only drug which has lethal withdrawl effects.

I did it the easy way -- move temporarily to Canada. Even back in '94 the swinging price of cigarettes up there did the trick.

Do you have "smoking dreams"?

I quit this year, too. Graduation day was the "official" day, but I kept it up for a few months after that, albeit only when drinking.

My best advice? Get all your friends to switch to menthols - and then bumming off them becomes so gross that you won't do it. It was honestly the most unexpectedly helpful thing in my quitting process. (The other helpful thing, of course, is smoking the greens)

I can't even remember when my last cigarette was. It feels really good. Now I just gotta get rid of the post-smoking weight bloat, which is a lot harder, to me anyway.

Gratz! In terms of your health probably the best thing you could have done.

I wonder if Obama has stayed on the wagon? Didn't he promise to quit since Michelle told him that was her prerequisite for him running?

Gratz! In terms of your health probably the best thing you could have done.

I wonder if Obama has stayed on the wagon? Didn't he promise to quit since Michelle told him that was her prerequisite for him running?

ITD w/your advice for people to consider not attempting to quit. The fact is it can take two or three or more (insert # it takes you personally) tries to actually break an addiction and most people don't get clean the first time they try to change.

You tried and failed and realized how the truly crappy part is the begining and then you just adjust to a new life. It's like this with all addictions.


I quit two years ago at age 49, probably a few years too late to avoid any permanent damage. I still miss smoking a little; but it's not a big deal.

I recommend decaf coffee as a bitter taste substitute. But the most important thing is to remember that acute cravings will always subside within ten minutes.

I've just gone about 10 days without a Marlboro, and I've been smoking better than a pack a day for about 35 years. Too soon to tell how it'll go -- talk to me a year from now -- but so far it's been pretty free of the sorts of withdrawal ugliness that MY describes (I'm more of an airhead than usual, though; can't concentrate for shit). I think the only reason it hasn't been worse is that lighting up, now, brings its own unpleasant sensations. My Pavlovian responses are in harmony.

More points for Bloomberg here, by the way. All through the 1990s, the smoking rate for NYC adults was flat at 21-22 percent. But since the City increased the tobaccor tax, banned smoking in bars & restaurants, and offered free nicotine patches to all New Yorkers in 2002-03, the smoking rate has dropped to 17.5%, the lowest ever. Big government works!

I didn't know about the free nicotine patches; that's alright. But in general it's my fervent hope that these sorts of sin taxes 1) divert smokers to other jurisdictions to get their cigs, and 2) encourage a healthy, thriving black market. These sorts of sin taxes are the worst kind of regressive political weaselry.

Quitting smoking is the easiest thing in the world to do...


... I've done it hundreds of times myself.

I find that quitting ANYTHING on January 1st is a bad idea, since you have to go back to work the next day and attempt to be productive. It's best to set aside a three-day weekend, clear your schedule, and do a great deal of sleeping.

In my experience, MLK Day -- conveniently located in the middle of a dull patch of January -- is the best time to enforce a New Year's Resolution.

Bill Kristol, Ann Coulter, and Rush Limbaugh WANT you to smoke!

(Picture that unholy triumvirate whenever you feel the urge.)

Good for you. I quit over seven years ago and we're probably the same age. There are always numerous failed attempts at quiting before you decide that you really just have to suck it up and take control of those receptors in your brain no matter what. The two biggest things I remember about quiting smoking were the amount of pain my lungs were in for weeks and the realization that the desire for a cigarette was not a product of a free will decision but rather was compelled upon me by a chemical need.

Also, I should note that an intense exercise regimen basically forces you to take good care of yourself because your body can't handle the strain unless you eat decently and refrain from intense consumption of chemicals. The more I exercise, the less liberty I have to drink or smoke.

Other good tricks: every day you smoke, donate $10 to the RNC or DC Chamber of Commerce.

Excellent post. I think "don't try this unless you honestly want it" is great advice on many topics. Lying to yourself isn't any healthier than smoking.

On the subject of WHY people start smoking, well, everyone's got their drugs that they like. Some drugs, like cigarettes, happen to be really, really bad for you and you eventually wind up having to quit or die.

I have smoked cigarettes all my adult life and I've never had a problem with it. I might smoke a pack in a week, then not smoke at all for three months. Other drugs are more seductive for me.

Lots of people think they aren't addicted to anything, but most of those people are addicted to being assholes.

RG

As a public health issue we should ban the selling of all tabacco products.

Congratulations, Matt, and as a sometimes insurance premium payer, thank you.

From one who failed at quitting several times before it took for good: The only way it will work is for smoking to be a complete taboo. You really can't ever have a single cigarette. Because if you do, you actually won't fall off the wagon immediately, but will falsely think that you can have an occasional cigarette without lapsing wholly back into the habit. But before you know it, "occasional" becomes more and more frequent. The slide off the wagon is often quite gradual.

My wife Sophia has had the same experience as Matt's. However, I think the ability to actually stop smoking entirely as a MEANS of quiting tends to correlate with a DESIRE to stop smoking. People who envision a lot of cigarette smoking as part of their vision of "quitting" are really doing something else, despite what they might call it.

RG

That should read "my wife Sophia has had the same experience as [strong]kth's[/strong]."

RG

I've been an on-and-off nicotine addict since I was 16--I've quit for as long as 5 years at a time, only to relapse. I'm currently smoking, as is my hubby, and we've set tomorrow as the next in a long line of quit dates. Fingers crossed. It was encouraging to read of your success.

Bill Kristol, Ann Coulter, and Rush Limbaugh WANT you to smoke!

When I first quit in 1990, I had a similar strategy. Every time I had a craving I envisioned Jesse Helms, complete with shit-eating grin, sitting in front of a big piggy bank. I would tell myself that every cigarette I had ever smoked was one more cha-ching to Sen. Helms' benefit. It helped.

The way people describe their reactions to nicotine is so completely at odds with anything I've experienced that I have to assume that their brains are wired differently than mine is.
Posted by Tyro

Same here. I've smoked off and on for about seven years now, since I was 18. I suppose I could make the same joke at Ethel-to-Tilly, because once or twice I did quit with the intention that it be permanent, but I've taken a few weeks or months off with no difficulty and I've never smoked as heavily as my friends who smoke. I don't think I've ever gone through a whole pack in a week.

Unfortunately, I think I am addicted to caffeine. I have two cups or more on most weekdays for the past year and usually no coffee on the weekends and I've had headaches on most Sunday mornings recently, and a friend pointed out that's probably not a coincidence.

Yay, Matt! Well done you!

I started about 10 years ago when I had a crazy roommate and my other roommate was a smoker - we would go outside so she could smoke while we commiserated. Of course, that got me started. A much-hated job kept me at it for years. I've quit a couple times, for a few months each, and have kept it down to an average 2 packs/week habit. Which is, obviously, 2 packs/week too much.

The best decision I ever made w/r/t paring down the habit was to leave my smokes at home. They never leave my house, so I don't smoke at work, at social events, or generally anywhere that I interact with other people. Also, I don't smoke inside my house. Only on my balcony do I smoke a few cigarettes before bed. This keeps it down, but still...

I'd like to quit but dread withdrawal. My job has changed so I lack that excuse nowadays. I like LFP's advice, and am taking MLK week off this year. Must strategize!

Some of us smoke irregularly (frequently termed "chippers") and would like to be left out of the addicted category. Alas, it seems that too many ex-smokers take the "humorless" and "AA" route (MY's words) and get all Puritan on everybody else. They can't enjoy a smoke, so they want to outlaw it everywhere, including inside a person's home, and also tax cigarettes up the wazoo (which is a cowardly way of avoiding taxing the rich).

How one approached cigarette smoking probably has a lot to do with it. I started at age 22 and don't smoke while driving, eating, working, etc. But I do like to have a couple at the end of the day, typically while listening to music. And for those curious, I can go for weeks without craving a cig. I might want one at times, but it's more like wanting a slice of apple pie, where you can easily switch to some other indulgence.

Some of us smoke irregularly (frequently termed "chippers") and would like to be left out of the addicted category. Alas, it seems that too many ex-smokers take the "humorless" and "AA" route (MY's words) and get all Puritan on everybody else.

Oh give it a break. You didn't notice that he wrote "for me at least"? You didn't notice that he referred to friends who smoke occasionally, like you? If you get so offended at the idea that someone else might choose to go the AA route themselves, I somehow doubt you're as happy with your own habit as you make out.

As for banning cigarettes in public places, it's a straightforward public health measure. The libertarian arguments against it apply just as much to meat inspections and laws against lead paint. I.e., to normal people, not all.

s/b not at all.

I agree that cold turkey is the only way to quit. I recommend quitting while on vacation. There's less likelihood of a stressful situation provoking a "need" to smoke. On the other hand it will be the worst vacation of your life. I don't know if my wife has forgiven me yet for being such a dick for those 10 days, and it's been five years. Once you've made it past the first couple of weeks it does get easier. I haven't had a smoking dream for probably three years.

Congratulations, Matt. One year is awesome. My wife and I took the same plunge 10 years ago tomorrow. We had to do the same and say "not even one, ever." and it worked. The first month or so was like a double case of PMS in our household but it was worth it. We've extended our lifetimes in very real and meaningful ways.

Like you, I got started around 15 and smoked a pack a day or so through the first half of college. For me, that turned into two packs of lucky strikes a day (just to be different, I transitioned from marlboro lights in highschool to camels in college, then to camel shorts and finally to lucky strikes) by the end of college along with the occasional clove and hand-rolled.

Then I met my wife and decided that if I lived to 100, that wouldn't be enough time on this planet with her and with both of us smoking, that was far from likely. We both quit together and while that was painful, it also worked in our favor. We had a sort of "I'm not going to be the first to cave" competition that was also motivated by the less spoken but more important bit that if one of us failed, we'd probably take the other down.

We both gained quite a bit of weight but that's a resolution for another year. Quitting smoking was the number one thing we could do to improve the lives we had together.

Good luck in year #2. It's not easy to quit smoking but it's also not terribly difficult to not have _one_ smoke. Don't have that _one_ and you'll be congratulating yourself on 10 years in no time.

- A

I'm glad when anyone quits smoking for however long and for whatever reason. I used to not mind hanging out with my smoking friends, sometimes found cigar and pipe smoke to smell pleasant. Lately, the allergies are such that walking past the lurking smokers, outside the door of wherever, will start up the sneezes. My father died of smoking just over 25 years ago. His lungs were destroyed by emphysema. It took a long time and the effects of not being able to breathe were horrible to behold. He didn't talk much by then so I can only assume that it was horrible to experience. My mother never smoked and as a good '50s era wife she didn't think she could complain about her husband's smoking. She died 6 years ago of lung cancer.
Good luck and happy new year.

I'm glad when anyone quits smoking for however long and for whatever reason. I used to not mind hanging out with my smoking friends, sometimes found cigar and pipe smoke to smell pleasant. Lately, the allergies are such that walking past the lurking smokers, outside the door of wherever, will start up the sneezes. My father died of smoking just over 25 years ago. His lungs were destroyed by emphysema. It took a long time and the effects of not being able to breathe were horrible to behold. He didn't talk much by then so I can only assume that it was horrible to experience. My mother never smoked and as a good '50s era wife she didn't think she could complain about her husband's smoking. She died 6 years ago of lung cancer.
Good luck and happy new year.

I'm glad when anyone quits smoking for however long and for whatever reason. I used to not mind hanging out with my smoking friends, sometimes found cigar and pipe smoke to smell pleasant. Lately, the allergies are such that walking past the lurking smokers, outside the door of wherever, will start up the sneezes. My father died of smoking just over 25 years ago. His lungs were destroyed by emphysema. It took a long time and the effects of not being able to breathe were horrible to behold. He didn't talk much by then so I can only assume that it was horrible to experience. My mother never smoked and as a good '50s era wife she didn't think she could complain about her husband's smoking. She died 6 years ago of lung cancer.
Good luck and happy new year.

I'm glad when anyone quits smoking for however long and for whatever reason. I used to not mind hanging out with my smoking friends, sometimes found cigar and pipe smoke to smell pleasant. Lately, the allergies are such that walking past the lurking smokers, outside the door of wherever, will start up the sneezes. My father died of smoking just over 25 years ago. His lungs were destroyed by emphysema. It took a long time and the effects of not being able to breathe were horrible to behold. He didn't talk much by then so I can only assume that it was horrible to experience. My mother never smoked and as a good '50s era wife she didn't think she could complain about her husband's smoking. She died 6 years ago of lung cancer.
Good luck and happy new year.

I'm glad when anyone quits smoking for however long and for whatever reason. I used to not mind hanging out with my smoking friends, sometimes found cigar and pipe smoke to smell pleasant. Lately, the allergies are such that walking past the lurking smokers, outside the door of wherever, will start up the sneezes. My father died of smoking just over 25 years ago. His lungs were destroyed by emphysema. It took a long time and the effects of not being able to breathe were horrible to behold. He didn't talk much by then so I can only assume that it was horrible to experience. My mother never smoked and as a good '50s era wife she didn't think she could complain about her husband's smoking. She died 6 years ago of lung cancer.
Good luck and happy new year.

Its all about baby steps guys, and anything is easy. You just have to stay focused on the objective. If you want to quit smoking, don't quit cold turkey. Just cut back. A pack a day. Then 19 cigs a day. Then 18 cigs a day. Then 17. Before you know it I'll be smoking a few cigs per day, then a few per week, then you'll forget that you want to smoke.

And if you go out and get drunk, have a couple of cigs. But the next day, go back to your alloted number.

Your new years resolution could be: reduce number of cigarettes smoke/day by 1 cigarette every 2 weeks for this entire year. You'll be over it by the end of the year.

Also it helps to fill in the void with intense cardiovascular exercise. Smoking 'feels' good on your lungs, but if you are breathing crazy hard then that feeling can be replicated. If you have a craving you can make it go away by a very hard workout.

Forgot to mention: every time you smoke, tell yourself that you hate it. It stinks, it is horrible for you, it is making you out of shape, its making you vulnerable to infection. Do this every time you smoke a cigarette. You will convince yourself eventually that it is true...

Its all about baby steps guys, and anything is easy. You just have to stay focused on the objective. If you want to quit smoking, don't quit cold turkey. Just cut back. A pack a day. Then 19 cigs a day. Then 18 cigs a day. Then 17. Before you know it I'll be smoking a few cigs per day, then a few per week, then you'll forget that you want to smoke.

Do you know anyone who's actually quit this way? because my experience is it doesn't work at all.

Like lemuel, I've tried the "tapering off" strategy any number of times and didn't find it helpful.

On the other hand, I can't agree strongly enough with someguy's recommendation of cardiovascular exercise--and I will be hitting the gym on 1/2/08.

Totally disagree with the tapering off approach. The only way to quit smoking is cold turkey, unfortunately -- that is, if you're really addicted. If you're not really addicted, then yeah cut down or whatever but what does it matter, you're just a chipper anyway?

One thing though is when attempting to go cold turkey if you get drunk and cave in, don't then say to yourself the next day, "Oh well, I guess I'm a smoker again..." and go out and buy a pack. The whole key is to stop buying packs. It's a good idea to not go into places where people smoke for about the first three months, so you're just not around anyone to mooch from.

Took me about 15 years longer to come to the same realization about 'social smoking' and my inability to ever be able to indulge.
Then again, I've always suspected you were smarter than me.

If you're trying to quit, you may find yourself thinking that the best way to make the pain of withdrawal go away is to smoke a cigarette.

Remember that that's not rational. The only way to make the withdrawal pain go away is to not smoke a cigarette.

If you smoke, the withdrawal will come back. It's only if you don't smoke that the withdrawal goes away.

Congratulations, Matt. I never started (my father was a four-pack-a-day-unfiltered-Camel smoker and died when I was five. That's an anniversary worth celebrating.

Here, by the way, is one the best anti-smoking warnings taken from a cigarette pack.

I'm 53. I, too, smoked when I was a teenager but was lucky enough to quit by age 20. I have a lot of friends who continued to smoke.

One has died of lung cancer. A few have had lumbar or cervical disc surgeries as a result of dessicated discs. Two have had heart attacks, one quadruple by-pass heart surgery, three stints.

All (including the females) have faces that look like leather, and look ten years older than they are. Their lungs don't work right. You can hear them catch their breath when they engage in normal conversation. As a result, they don't exert themselves and are all out of shape. Their teeth are stained or falling out. They stink.

I'll outlive all of'em.

Congratulations. Don't start back. In a couple of years, you'll wonder how you ever could have smoked one of those things.

I never smoked. Not cigarettes, not pot. Because I was reasonably rational from day one and couldn't see any point in inhaling and blowing out smoke, then coughing, getting cancer, etc. (And getting cancer wasn't even a given back in the 60's.) The same with drinking - getting drunk wasn't an option and alcohol tasted like cough syrup to me.

"people who smoked the odd cigarette socially or maybe even in some moment of crucial stress"

Oh, yeah, start with the excuses. Winona Ryder talks about "smoking socially", too - which is why every picture of her in public shows her with a cigarette. Like she doesn't smoke when NOT in public. I'll buy that for a dollar. Much as I like her, she's a cigarette addict.

Cigarettes are physically addicting, Matt. You do not smoke them "socially" - it's not cocaine or pot. Even heroin - you might get away with shooting a fairly large jolt of that without being immediately addicted. Whereas one cigarette shows clinical signs of addiction in the body.

I read a book by someone who analyzed the whole "War on Drugs" thing some years ago. The most interesting theory he had on why people do drugs like cigarettes is that it enables them to "schedule" pleasure. As he pointed out, you have to WANT to be addicted to get addicted to cigarettes because there's no advantage to smoking just one. But once you're addicted, you KNOW that within a short while you will be experiencing some pleasure. Life gets broken up into a series of scheduled pleasurable moments, whereas without addiction it doesn't - unless you've organized your life that way.

I assume he wasn't saying that this was necessarily a conscious choice on the part of addicts. But it almost certainly is a subconscious choice. And people chose such things for reasons - the unexamined life, as Aristotle put it.

You want kids? I told a smoking female correctional worker while I was in the joint, "You don't want your kids burying you twenty years early, do you?" That had an impact on her as a mother, she admitted later.

Well, there are a lot of things that can kill you. Heck, when I was young, the hardware store sold asbestos in brown paper bags (the stuff was too cheap to have a brand name) and some of the bags on the shelf were broken. Ha ha, I guess I'll deal with that problem when I reach it.

In some ways I think I've been lucky. My dad smoked two packs a day for 60 years and did not die from a lung problem. YMMV.

And the chances are that with all the research going on about what can kill you, you're going to feel lucky too.

Unless you live too long.

tonight is my last night. wish me luck.

"...it's not really worth entering into lightly."

I would apply that sentiment to smoking, not quitting smoking.

Yes, quitting smoking voluntarily is, for many people, very hard (though others find it easy, no one can account for the difference). I've known people who have had both cigarrette and heroin problems, and found heroin easier to quit. But, even if you're one of the people who finds quitting voluntarily unusually difficult, it's still a whole lot easier than being forced to quit. The things that force you to quit tend to be even more brutal, by several orders of magnitude, than nicotine pangs. These are things like your first heart attack, lung cancer, worsening chronic bronchitis, or, if you're lucky, merely the prospect of making a child an orphan. These are the things, the things that force you to quit, that should really, really not be entered into lightly. But the only way off the light and easy path to these things is to quit voluntarily.

Not that it is a public disservice to warn people that quitting might be hard. In fact, I think that message whould be more widely disseminated (though not to exclusion -- many people do not find it at all difficult to quit -- you don't know until you try). More than half of the people I have talked to about how they quit, found the motivation to succeed only after the miserable failure of several attempts convinced them viscerally just how much of a hold the habit had on them.

Dr. Dean Ornish describes why it's easier to go cold turkey than to taper off gradually, and I've found it to be true when I gave up meat and eventually dairy.

He says, if you want to go from whole milk to skim milk, yet you do it gradually, by drinking whole milk every other day, you'll never get the taste of whole milk out of your mind. You'll always find something lacking with skim milk, whereas if you start drinking skim milk and never again drink whole milk, you'll soon find it just as satisfying as whole milk.

I never could stand milk of any kind, so I don't really understand that bit, but it's true, when I gave up meat completely, I soon came to feel there was nothing at all missing from my diet. Not even the occasional cold turkey.

Big deal, I've quit smoking something like 10 times. It's easy.

I feel an urge to apologize for yesterday's repetitive post disorder. I'll try not to stutter this time.
My father started smoking at age 16 but joined the Army shortly after high school graduation to fight in WWII.
My father never mentioned this but another man of his generation told me that he (the other guy) began smoking in the Army because cigarettes were freely available to soldiers and, if he smoked, he could get more breaks. He said the smokers in his group got cigarette breaks and the non-smokers didn't get to stop working so, as a young guy, smoking was a no-brainer. Maybe we can consider that generation innocent victims of their addiction. They really didn't know how bad it was and their drug was handed to them by the grateful nation in their USO packages.
By the time, my father could have known how bad it was, I think his addiction was so strong that he truly couldn't stop.
I am happy when anyone gets themselves out of the grip of any addiction.

This post, which I think describes very well the dynamics of quitting for a quitter who doesn’t disapprove of smoking, inspired some reflections on desire, autonomy, and the good life here.


Comments closed January 14, 2008.

Copyright © 2007 by The Atlantic Monthly Group. All rights reserved.