« McCain and Choice | Main | Obama on the Economy »

Day One

14 Feb 2008 02:17 pm

mccainready.jpg

Jon Chait wonders if John McCain is deliberately echoing Hillary Clinton's campaign themes in an effort to face her in the primary: "Every poll now shows Obama performing better than Clinton against McCain. On average, he does five and a half points better than her, which is a very significant margin." Chait has in mind McCain's rather implausible efforts to cast himself as the candidate of policy details, but I clicked over to McCain's website today and was surprised to see that the slogan reproduced above.

This raises the possibility that McCain's campaign team is just lazy. After all, they can't be bothered to out-organized Mike Huckabee even though he's got no money and no machine support. Maybe all they do all day is hang back, look at which Democrat is leading in the polls, and rip off the other one's campaign themes. Mac is Back, in ur base rippin off ur narrativz.

Share This

Comments (28)

I think you underestimate the probability of a McCain win. All he has to do is to select some loathsome wingnut, who is a hero to the warmongers and kill all the brownies wing of the GOP, as his running mate and he gets all the Republican votes and over half of the votes of the so-called moderates, especially with a strategically timed terror alert by McCain's new BFF, and the dems are toast in November.

Well, if McCain is seen as trying to boost Clinton's candidacy, that certainly helps Obama. And every minute McCain devotes to criticizing Obama gives Obama another way to say "Look, they're afraid of me."

Maybe he thought the "Ready to lead from day one" line would work better for a candidate who was, you know, ready to lead from day one.

Hey, he's "fired up and ready to go," too. It's amazing how much both Clinton and McCain have pilfered from Obama, and for good reason.

Honestly, if he wants to run the same narratives that have lead to Obama winning independents 2:1 vs. Clinton, I'm all for it.

McCain ought to be poaching from Bob Dole. They're both old, veteran sour pusses whose most compelling rationale for their candidacies is that they paid their dues and now it's their turn.

right, the only thing McCain is ready to lead on day one is this country right off a cliff.

And ready to take a long nap on day two.

John McCain

Ready to Lead on Day One

Ready for a Nap on Day Two

Perhaps he's lazy. But McCain is trying to pick his opponent, like Chait said.

in ur base rippin off ur narrativz.

This joke was kind of funny .... in mid-2005 .... when made by 14-year olds.

Damn blah. That was eerie.

i think the notion that a 5.5% lead in the polls in frickin' mid-february is not significant in the slightest: wait until the gop really warms up its attack lines on obama - his negatives will shoot right up to clinton/kerry territory. good grief, lots of americans are just starting to think about the presidential election.

It's not a bad strategy as far as it goes. If Hillary is the nominee, he has neutralized that message. If Obama is the candidate, he gets to piggy-back on the case Hillary has been building. "Gee, even respected Democrats don't think he's ready on day one."

I don't think it's a particularly brilliant strategy though.

It's more likely that McCain thinks Obama will be the Democratic nominee-- and so Clinton voters who consider Obama to be unready to be President will be attracted to a Hillary-like message. And actually copying Hillary's slogans is a not-entirely-stupid way of appealing to those voters.

Um, McCain's had the Day One thing up for months and months.

I don't think this page has changed since his website went live:

http://www.johnmccain.com/Undecided/WhyMcCain.htm

The Union Leader's endorsement is from Dec. 2:

http://www.unionleader.com/article.aspx?articleID=dfca72c2-4a23-49e5-943f-1d85256f45cc

An "internal" memo from September:

http://marcambinder.theatlantic.com/archives/2007/09/mccains_road_to_victory_an_act.php

From August:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Xf6QbOjYug

Of course they're ripping off Hillary's slogan and Obama's words. Innovation, creativity, and freshness is not something that we'll be seeing out of the McCain camp.

And actually copying Hillary's slogans is a not-entirely-stupid way of appealing to those voters.

I dunno, I don't think he'd look nearly as good in a pantsuit as Giuliani.

How is 5 1/2 points that significant? Isn't it within the margin of error, and hence totally meaningless?

MattF I think gets it right...they may think that they there is a real portion working class and older voters who simply don't trust Obama, think he's too green, and are legit attracted to Clinton's message of "experience" and being "ready to lead", and not just responding to the warm and fuzzies they associate with the economic boom of the 90's.

I suspect he might actually be right with some of the 65+ voting bloc, but not with the working class voting block. And if McCain wants to marginalize himself as the geezer candidate, by all means.

And ready to take a long nap on day two.

Fantastic (blah and DanK)

It beats "ready to keel over on Day One" or "ready take a nap at 1 o'clock".

Damn, I see someone beat me to it and did it better.

While the candidates have promised what they will do On Day One, let's actually have a say and tell them what we WISH they would do the first day. Visit OnDayOne.org!

Ok, I often tend to rip on Matt, but I do love the lolcat-based ending to his post. Kudos.

5.5 points on average *is* significant if you average all of the polls together, folks. And a big benefit of this extended primary season is that people in a lot of swing states have gotten a good long look at Obama. The results:

CO (Rasmussen 2/12)
Obama 46
McCain 39

NV (Rasmussen 2/13)
Obama 50
McCain 38

IA (SUSA post-caucus)
Obama 55
McCain 38

Clinton loses all 3 by 4+ points. That's way, way outside the MOE.

I will continue to support Barack and if the democrats are dumb enough to nominate Hillary, I think we can survive a McCain presidency cause that is what is going to happen, take it to the bank.

"Ready for a Nap on Day Two"

Does this mean McCain will have even more "vacation" days, er, weeks, er, months, than Bush?

'Cause right now Bush can run on the "All Vacation All The Time" ticket.

At least when Clinton was getting blowjobs, he was in the office.

Hey, he's "fired up and ready to go," too

Maybe McCain is really a Deadhead for Obama


What's the point of previewing? Stupid link doesn't work now!

Deadheads for Obama:

http://tinyurl.com/2dyz72


Comments closed February 28, 2008.

Copyright © 2008 by The Atlantic Monthly Group. All rights reserved.