« More Good News for McCain | Main | Black Swans »

Independent Streaks

31 Jul 2008 11:02 am

251647296_e654629b22.jpg

Oftentimes policies designed to protect the environment involve difficult tradeoffs with economic growth. But sometimes they don't. Sometimes we have bad policies in place that encourage people to use space or energy wastefully, and these policies are both bad for the environment and bad for economic growth -- waste is bad. When confronted with such policies, politicians have an aggravating tendency to gesture in the direction of local culture suggesting that people in their jurisdictions just happen to have, as quirk, a strong desire to see resources used poorly. Thus via Robert Farley, we get Houston Mayor Bill White explaining why his city has such a low recycling rate:

“We have an independent streak that rebels against mandates or anything that seems trendy or hyped up,” said Mayor Bill White, who favors expanding the city’s recycling efforts. “Houstonians are skeptical of anything that appears to be oversold or exaggerated. But Houstonians can change, and change fast.”

As Farley says, when you read things like "25,000 Houston residents have been waiting as long as 10 years to get recycling bins from the city . . . the city says it cannot afford more bins" you start to wonder if an independent streak and an aversion to hype is really to blame here. Like maybe if the city provided bins to people who ask for bins, then more people would recycle. Or maybe we're supposed to believe that Houston's independent streak extends to a desire to have government services provided ineptly.

Photo by Flickr user dnorman used under a Creative Commons license

Share This

Comments (24)

He's missing the word "politicians". It should read "Houstonian politicians are skeptical of anything that appears to be oversold or exaggerated. But Houstonian politicians can change, and change fast."

Some people's contrarian, reactionary, anti-trendy attitudes extend to the point of absurdity and masochism, and there' very little to do but hope that they don't breed. Just the other day I was walking towards the Arlington T stop in Boston and I watched as this 20-year-old Boston goon (wearing a cheap Red Sox jersey, camo shorts, and swagger) told the earnest Greenpeace canvasser that he "drives a gas guzzler and is proud of it!" (He later muttered to his girlfriend that the Greenpeacer was a "tree-hugging pussy".) This is insane, of course. Why would any rational human being be proud to own or drive an automobile whose inefficient engine requires that you spend a lot more money, some of which goes to finance "terror" and other things that your preferred politicians seem concerned about? But the point of pride is in the contrarianism and the "fuck you" to the perceived fagginess of Greenpeace or whatever. The important thing is to show that you aren't a pussy, or a trend-follower, or a Hollywood liberal homo. The kid would rather blow money out his truck's exhaust pipe than, say, have extra cash to buy an authentic Jason Varitek jersey.

I think Mayor White's explanation that "we have an independent streak that rebels against mandates or anything that seems trendy or hyped up" is substantively correct, although he's spinning it as a positive attribute, rather than as a negative one. As someone who has lived in the Houston area my entire life, I can assure you that this attitude is real and fundamentally opposed to anything that smacks of cooperation, or ceeding individual prerogatives for the larger, public good. It is, sadly, part of the ingrained Texan culture that we seem to consider ourselves separate and apart from all others, bound by none of the limits that might apply to mere others (see also: liberals, aetheists, the French).

It is classic exceptionalism, with a twang, behind the wheel of an F-150.

I live in Houston, and just got a letter from the City saying they are going to discontinue recycling in my neighborhood because it wasn't being utilized enough. All I know is that every recycling day, there is at least one full bin in front of more than 90% of the homes on my street. Wonder what gives?

As a newcomer to the city, I have to say: If the roads here are any indication, then inept government services are deeply ingrained in Houston culture.

I live in Houston, and just got a letter from the City saying they are going to discontinue recycling in my neighborhood because it wasn't being utilized enough. All I know is that every recycling day, there is at least one full bin in front of more than 90% of the homes on my street.

As a newcomer to the city, I have to say: If the roads here are any indication, then inept government services are deeply ingrained in Houston culture.

I can't get a recycling bin in Montgomery County (MD), but they don't seem to have a problem picking up the recyclables out of a regular trash can that I've marked "Recycling". What's the matter with Houstonites that they can't do something similar?

I live in Houston, and have had a recycling bin since we bought our home in 2004. We called last week to ask for a second one (for glass), and one was dropped off at our house within two days.

We also received a letter indicating that curbside recycling would be terminated if not utilized, which seems odd because almost every home in the neighborhood appears to take advantage of this. I wonder if this is just some way to prod people to actually use the service more; I'll be surprised if there are any terminations in any neighborhoods which recycle heavily.

It's in Texas, so don't bother allowing for reason.

It is the town that oil built.

Houston has a lot of poor people and a lot of anti-regulation Republicans, two demographics that probably are not big on recycling.

Or possibly, the city knows that recycling costs more than trash collection, the market for the stuff collected is poor, and landfills are not, in fact, filling up.

Matt, trees are the biggest source of pollution.

Hey, let's all send our trash to Houston, since they won't appear to mind!

For a long time in my part of Houston (well actually too far outside of town to still be houston) we had no recycling bins, no way to get them.

Then I came home one day and every house in the Neighborhood had a large red bin on their doorstep. I would say since that day 75% of the houses put it out every Friday Morning.

So Mayor White is VERY WRONG, the city is just waiting for the service. I went to the "Recycling Center" which was just a bunch of receptacles inside a fenced in area, and it was full of people dropping off items to be recycled. Too bad they all have to drive 10+ miles to recycle simple items.

I had the misfortune of living in Houston for a year, many years ago. The politicians/business interests that dominate the system there hate regulations or anything that smacks of do-gooderism. Half the time the traffic lights didn't even work! And the roads, as another commenter notes, are a disaster. At the time I was there (early 1980's), the population had quadrupled in the past decade, but the police force hadn't increased at all, and episodes of police brutality (usually against poor blacks and Hispanics) were common. Meanwhile, the wealthy River Oaks neighborhood had its own private police force, something I had never seen before or since. Houston sums up everything I despise about Texas, the South, the GOP and corporate wealth.

To defend Houston - Becky, all I'll say is it has become a far better city since the 80's, when it was a mess and all of your descriptions were accurate.

Enough on that.

As a fan of Mayor White's, I think his explanation as to why Houston is bad at recycling is a bit too glib. There is a recycling center near our (inner city) home and the weekend crowd of homeowners dropping stuff off there is huge.

There are a number of cultural reasons why Houston hasn't adapted to recycling but the big issue is that the city has never invested anything in attempting to educate the populace as to its convenience and necessity (but..but..we have a solid waste department website that says recycling is good!). There is an attitude that recycling is no good unless it turns a profit for someone, which is, of course, absurd.

If the city leadership was serious about recycling and invested some time and money in pushing it - rather than saying, "we're going to cancel the program if you don't participate," which is the current strategy, the city would come around.

Waiting years for recyling bins? My town doesn't bother to give them out anymore - just put your paper/magazines in paper bags, bottles & cans in a cardboard box or plastic garbage can - gets picked up every week.
I have one neighbor who puts her recyclables in a Martha Stewart wicker basket - out on the curb every week.

I recall my time spent in Houston and at first glance at the huge mosquitoes hovering over the trash in the photograph, I realized just one of the reasons I left.

No those aren't seagulls.

Houstonians are skeptical of anything that appears to be oversold or exaggerated??? I guess that explains Enron...

I can't believe people are still trying to cram recycling down everyone's throats. It's completely useless if not harmful.

Houston is ummm…. Houston. While Houston is the fourth largest city in the country, it is nothing like Chicago, the third largest city. Chicago outclasses Houston in almost every aspect except job growth.

Most of that difference is likely because of the whole Houston is a kid city and the whole boom town effect. Houston is very much a growing boom townish anything goes wild west sort of place. Houston doesn’t even have zoning laws. As far as recycling in Houston goes, yeah….., well…., this is a city that has just barely illegal brothels, and lots of them.

Why do they neeed city bins? Why not allow recycling from any sort of container (within reason) as long as it's labeled "recycling"?

Oftentimes policies designed to protect the environment involve difficult tradeoffs with economic growth.

Matt, could you (or anyone else) cite an example?


Comments closed August 14, 2008.

Copyright © 2008 by The Atlantic Monthly Group. All rights reserved.